Full Schedule for Cake Eaters in the Fall / Winter 2019 / 20
| Game # | Away Team | Home Team | Location | Game Type | Date | Time | Recap/ Preview |
| 31773 | Viking Pest Control 1 | Cake Eaters 2 | Ice House 4 | League Game | 10-13-2019 | 7:40 PM | Full Recap |
| 31557 | Blue Devils (Smythe) 4 | Cake Eaters 5 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 10-20-2019 | 8:30 PM | Full Recap |
| 31563 | Cake Eaters 5 | Bulldogs 2 | Ice House 4 | League Game | 10-27-2019 | 8:30 PM | Full Recap |
| 31572 | Cake Eaters 9 | The Yeti 0 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 11-04-2019 | 9:15 PM | Full Recap |
| 31578 | Enforcers (North) 6 | Cake Eaters 4 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 11-11-2019 | 9:15 PM | Full Recap |
| 31582 | Cake Eaters 5 | Gators 0 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 11-17-2019 | 10:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31589 | Mustangs 7 | Cake Eaters 6 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 11-24-2019 | 10:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31591 | Cake Eaters 6 | Misfits 3 | Ice House 1 | League Game | 12-08-2019 | 7:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31602 | Hoboken Rockets 7 | Cake Eaters 6 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 12-16-2019 | 9:15 PM | Full Recap |
| 31605 | Cake Eaters 2 | Seals 2 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 01-05-2020 | 9:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31614 | Yeshiva District 4 | Cake Eaters 5 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 01-13-2020 | 9:15 PM | Full Recap |
| 31616 | Cake Eaters 2 | Viking Pest Control 7 | Ice House 1 | League Game | 01-19-2020 | 8:30 PM | Full Recap |
| 31624 | Cake Eaters 1 | Blue Devils (Smythe) 3 | Ice House 1 | League Game | 01-26-2020 | 10:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31631 | Bulldogs 6 | Cake Eaters 3 | Ice House 3 | League Game | 02-09-2020 | 10:30 PM | Full Recap |
| 31638 | The Yeti 5 | Cake Eaters 3 | Ice House 2 | League Game | 02-17-2020 | 9:15 PM | Full Recap |
| 31639 | Cake Eaters 1 | Enforcers (North) 9 | Ice House 1 | League Game | 02-23-2020 | 7:00 PM | Full Recap |
| 31800 | Cake Eaters 8 | Hoboken Rockets 5 | Ice House 1 | Playoff Game | 03-01-2020 | 8:30 PM | Full Recap |
| 31818 | Yeshiva District 5 | Cake Eaters 0 | Ice House | Playoff Game | 03-08-2020 | 8:30 PM | Full Recap |